Top 15 Best Antlers for Dogs Available in 2020

0
20
Best Antlers for Dogs

If your dog has an antler and you have hardwood floors, you know where he is at all times. You’ll either hear him gnawing on it or hear it slapping your floors as he moves across the rooms.

The bad news? That chew toy may be hard on your floors. Consider letting him play with it in a carpeted room (or rug) instead.

The good news? If you purchased the best antlers for dogs, you can keep your chew-happy dog from chomping on furniture and/or knocking over other delicate items in the room. Your fragile vase, picture frames, and remote controls can now survive in peace. And deer antlers for dogs can be thanked for it.

But before you grab the first elk antlers in the pet aisle, know which one makes the most sense. Split antlers are ideal for mild chewers who can associate it with a tasty marrow center.

Whole antler dog chews work out better for aggressive chewers to stay busy trying to get to the marrow center. And these 15 options below should help to entertain your pup for days or weeks on end.

1. Barkworthies Split & Whole

Barkworthies

Barkworthies

CHECK ON AMAZON

Considering how sensitive dogs are to smell, try finding antlers that don’t have an off-putting smell to them. Otherwise, the dog won’t touch it.

Key Features

  • Available in three chew types (light, medium, hard)
  • Four split elk antlers for dogs for various sizes (puppy, medium, large, X-large)
  • Four whole elk antlers for dogs for various sizes (puppy, medium, large, X-large)

This odor-free antler chew has been sanded down to a safe size for dogs to chew. Shed by roaming elk, these antlers are hand-selected, cut and sanded down to premium versions that are safe to chew.

And, if you’re not into brushing your dog’s teeth, this does a pretty good job of scraping away plaque and tartar from your pet’s gumline.

Pros

  • No chemical treatments
  • No added preservatives

Cons

  • Refund and/or replacement policy unclear
  • Several users complained of splinters and “toothpick” thinness

In addition to teaching your dog safe chewing, this flavorful marrow center version is perfect for aggressive chewers for all ages and sizes.

2. Big Dog Chews

Premium Dog Chews

Premium Dog Chews

CHECK ON AMAZON

Intended for medium and large dogs, this package will arrive with a mixture of split and whole antler pieces to choose from.

Key Features

  • 100 percent natural
  • 1 pound of premium Grade A antler pieces (four to six antler pieces)
  • Six-inch long pieces

If you’re used to antlers that are messy with pieces all over the floor, these custom cut, trimmed and sanded versions should be better for indoor use. Additionally, they do not have that strange odor found on other antlers.

Pros

  • No chemicals
  • No added preservatives

Cons

  • Money-back guarantee only covered by the only authorized seller (Big Dog Antler Chews)
  • Not ideal for small dogs

The “Happy Dog Guarantee” for these antlers are covered by a money-back guarantee if you or your pooch are not 100 percent satisfied.

3. Heartland

Elk Antlers

Elk Antlers

CHECK ON AMAZON

Made with no additives or preservatives, these dog antler chews represent the top 10-15 percent of elk antlers.

Key Features

  • Available in three sizes (large split, large 7-9 inches, X-large 9-11 inches)
  • Premium, Grade-A elk
  • Vitamins and minerals included

This bully stick has no fillers and is intended for long-lasting chewing to stimulate your dog’s attention all day. Not suitable for small dogs, these larger versions should work well for medium-size dogs to munch on longer and large dogs.

Make sure that the antler cannot fully fit into the dog’s mouth to avoid choking or small parts becoming chipped or stuck inside the dog’s gums and/or teeth.

Pros

  • No animals harmed
  • Naturally shed

Cons

  • Refund and/or warranty policy is unclear
  • One reviewer mentioned how the antler was thin on one side and thick on the other, making it too easy for her dog to go to the thinner side to get to the marrow faster

This company does not sell weathered, light-colored antlers (Grade B, Grade C, Grade D) that are usually found in cheaper brands with less nutrients.

4. Big Dog Antler Chews

Big Dog Chews

Big Dog Chews

CHECK ON AMAZON

This jumbo deer antler is intended to keep your large and/or X-large dog busy from aggressively chewing on everything else in your home.

Key Features

  • Grade A premium quality deer antler
  • Six inches
  • Extra thick texture

Great for tartar control, this antler can work for indoor use. Although it does guard against greasy messes on your floor, keeping the antler in a contained environment (i.e. dog bed or carpet piece) helps, too. There should not be an odor either on this custom cut, trimmed and sanded product.

Pros

  • No chemicals
  • No added preservatives

Cons

  • Several users compared it to chewing on stone or rocks
  • Another user said the antler broke in an hour

The “Happy Dog Guarantee” only honors purchased from the authorized seller, Big Dog Antler Chews. With that, there is a money-back guarantee.

5. Pet Parents Gnawtlers

Pet Parents Gnawtlers

Pet Parents Gnawtlers

CHECK ON AMAZON

Specially selected from The Heartland Regions, these naturally shed deer antlers are perfect for small dogs, teething puppies and adult dogs, too.

Key Features

  • Four inches
  • Vacuum sealed for dog’s safety
  • Available in small, medium, large

These antlers are meticulously sorted, weighed, cut, sanded, inspected and ready to be gnawed as soon as the vacuum seal is removed. It is vacuum-sealed to avoid any contaminants from getting on the antler before your dog can put her mouth on it.

Pros

  • No odor
  • No messy residue

Cons

  • Gnawtler Standard is unclear on the warranty policy
  • One user’s puppy received a second antler that resulted in her throwing up

This cruelty-free product has natural ingredients intended to keep puppy, adolescents, adult and senior dogs. However, it should literally be gnawed on, not bitten on. If you find your dog trying to aggressively bite the antler, take it away immediately.

6. Heartland

Premium Chew

Premium Chew

CHECK ON AMAZON

This long-lasting antler is premium, Grade A and intended to keep your dog busy.

Key Features

  • Available in two sizes: Medium (4-6 inches), Large (6-8 inches)
  • 100 percent all natural
  • Hard texture intended for lengthy chewing

Although some reviewers confirmed that the antler ended up being a choking mechanism for some dogs, it was a hit for other heavy chewers. One user referred to it as the “ultimate chew for a strong-jawed dog.”

Pros

  • No processing
  • No additives or preservatives

Cons

  • One user found a shard of metal inside, according to one reviewer
  • One dog’s owner found a thick sliver of bone in the dog’s throat

This antler is covered by a 100 percent, no-questions-asked satisfaction guarantee. But the warranty description is not fully clear.

7. Elkhorn Premium Giant Chews

Giant Chew

Giant Chew

CHECK ON AMAZON

This whole jumbo antler is not only Grade A premium, but the no-mess, no-odor dog chew toy is intended for your largest dogs.

Key Features

  • XX-Large whole chews
  • 100 percent premium grade
  • 100 percent natural shed

This whole antler is hand-cut and smoothed out to reduce hard, sharp edges. This renewable version comes courtesy of bull elk who naturally drop their antlers before growing a new set. This is both a renewable and sustainable way to create healthy dog chews.

Pros

  • 100 percent renewable
  • No additives or preservatives

Cons

  • Not intended for small dogs
  • Warranty and/or refund policy is unclear

Perfect for indoor and outdoor use, this antler is intended for indoor and outdoor use.

8. Deer Valley

Antler Treats

Antler Treats

CHECK ON AMAZON

This all-natural, anti-anxiety chew option can be used as a way to calm down anxious dogs who have trouble being away from their owners. While it should not be chewed on without supervision, it may come in handy for dog sitters or other non-dog owners.

Key Features

  • Three-pack
  • Five to seven inches
  • Premium grade #1 or #2

This chemical-free set of three antlers is natural. After being washed, it is shipped directly to you. The all-natural chews are suitable both indoors and outdoors.

Pros

  • Organic
  • Hypoallergenic

Cons

  • One owner got all skinny tips
  • Couple of dogs grew bored with the chews

These antlers are covered by a 30-day, money-back guarantee.

9. Devil Dog Pet Co.

Premium Bone

Premium Bone

CHECK ON AMAZON

These wild-sourced antlers are long lasting and intended for aggressive chewers.

Key Features

  • Premium Grade A
  • 100 percent organic
  • Available in seven sizes (small, medium, large, X-large, XX-large, monster)

These elk antler chews are intended to physically and mentally stimulate your dog from day to day. Made from the highest quality 5 percent of antler chews, these are clean and odorless.

Pros

  • Cruelty-free
  • All-natural

Cons

  • No refund and/or warranty policy stated
  • Owners either noticed their dogs lost interest due to the antlers slipping around or finding it too hard to chew

In addition to stimulating your dog, a percentage of every sale is donated to a rescue organization at the end of every month.

10. The Antler Box

Premium Box

Premium Box

CHECK ON AMAZON

As mentioned in the promo, the weight of the antlers matters far more than how many are received. This will not only confirm the quality but how likely it will be to shed or splinter too quickly (or at all).

Key Features

  • One pound bulk pack
  • Whole and split antlers
  • Available in small, medium, large, X-large sizes

These naturally shed antlers are mainly from the Rocky Mountain range. The plastic-free eco-packaging avoids wasteless plastic used on a natural product. For environmentally friendly dog owners, this matters quite a bit.

Pros

  • Should not splinter
  • Biodegradable

Cons

  • Refund and/or warranty policy unclear
  • May be unclear of which ones are split and which ones aren’t

Keep in mind that the photograph of antlers may not be what you get. While you should receive 1 pound of antlers, it may just be one or two total.

11. Deluxe Naturals

Deluxe Naturals Split

Deluxe Naturals Split

CHECK ON AMAZON

Each antler in these deluxe packages is sanitized and packaged immediately to avoid any contamination. After all, the goal is to make sure it’s safe for your dog to chew.

Key Features

  • Available in five sizes (small, medium, large, giant)
  • Option for split or whole antlers
  • Available in single packs, two-packs, four-packs, and six-packs

These dog antlers are free of antibiotics and preservatives. In a package of four, they’re intended for gentle chewers and aggressive chewers.

Pros

  • Cruelty free
  • No growth hormones

Cons

  • No warranty and/or refund policy stated on site
  • Couple of dogs ended up with bloody diarrhea or

Be careful when ordering multi-packs if you want both whole and/or split antlers.

12. Perfect Pet

Perfect Pet

Perfect Pet

CHECK ON AMAZON

Skip the chemical enhancements with these all-natural antler dog chews.

Key Features

  • Available in three sizes (small, small long, medium)
  • All-natural products
  • Intended for aggressive chewers

These premium North American shed antlers not only promote good hygiene but also avoid are made to avoid altering the natural state of the dog chews.

Pros

  • Cruelty-free
  • No dyes or preservatives

Cons

  • Refund and/or warranty policy unclear
  • Choking hazard for small dogs

This five-count of antlers may work out well for some dogs. For others, the skinnier, long pieces may pose a problem. Watch your dog carefully when choosing these antlers.

13. Petstages Elkridge

Petstages

Petstages

CHECK ON AMAZON

If you’re not sure which size is best for your dog, especially teething dogs who may still be getting used to their teeth (regardless of size), this set of three in all different sizes may be helpful.

Key Features

  • Durable nylon strength
  • Made with real natural antler
  • Multiple textures to help clean teeth

Although these antlers are supposed to split or splinter, pay special attention teach set should you buy more than one. Because it’s not all-natural antlers for dogs, their appearance may vary.

Pros

  • Non-toxic
  • Naturally shed

Cons

  • Not real antlers
  • Has an odor

This version may be lighter than real antlers, so prepare for the weight difference. The texture will undoubtedly be different, too.

14. WhiteTail Naturals

WhiteTail Naturals

WhiteTail Naturals

CHECK ON AMAZON

These antler dog chews are ideal for medium-sized dogs. They have been washed, custom cut, trimmed and sanded for your dog’s gnawing pleasure.

Key Features

  • Three-pack (assorted sizes)
  • All-natural ingredients
  • Five to six inches in length

These mess-free antlers are long-lasting and naturally packed with minerals. There are also no added ingredients in these premium antlers. The weight of them may vary. Some reviewers say they’re tough and hard while others stated they were light and durable.

Pros

  • Odor free
  • No preservatives or chemicals

Cons

  • Not ideal for dogs more than 40 pounds
  • Refund and/or warranty policy is unclear

As with any dog, antler preferences are hard to determine. But the owner’s dogs enjoyed these antlers so much that the three of them take turns. According to the owner, they take turns with each one of the three, but there’s one that’s the favorite. Hopefully your dog will have a favorite of the three, too.

15. Nylabone Dura

Nylabone Power

Nylabone Power

CHECK ON AMAZON

This durable antler dog chew is intended for aggressive chewers who are up to 50 pounds. These dog chews assist your dog in fighting against destructive chewing, stress, anxiety, and boredom, in addition to dental cleaning.

Key Features

  • Six to 11 inches long
  • Available in two sizes (giant and wolf)
  • Venison flavor

These chews contain venison flavors that dogs love. The Nylabone collection has four dog category options: chew toys, chew treats, dental solutions, and puppy products. Made for puppies, active adults and gentle seniors, this brand can be used to entertain your dog through every phase.

Pros

  • Challenges aggressive chewers
  • Splinter-free for safe chewing

Cons

  • Not intended for small dogs
  • Refund and/or warranty policy unclear

As with every other antler, some dogs had a bad reaction to it (vomiting, stomach aches, splinters) while others were a great timesaver and kept the dogs entertained throughout the day.

Dog Antler Safety Tips

labradoodle chewing a bone

As you can see from the cons above for all 15 antler options, they’re not all created equal. So with all of the concerns regarding antlers, why buy them anyway? The simple answer is that for some dogs, these antler options are great. They keep your dog busy.

Dogs can control their anxiety and loneliness. And they can avoid boredom, especially in smaller quarters where they can’t run around.

Supervision certainly helps to make sure that your dog behaves well with a sharp, rough chew toy like this. It also comes in handy for your dog, knowing just how far he can go to get to the marrow without hurting himself.

Some veterinarians recommend skipping dog antlers altogether. Others leave it up to the owner. But just as antlers can be fun toys as well as a safety hazard, so can any other toy for dogs (or children) without proper operation. Pay attention to which size dog the manufacturer thinks is suitable for your dog.

Checking Antlers for Flawed Spots and Best Options

an old shepherd mix chews on a bone, white background

When you purchase a dog antler, make sure to look it over beforehand. Ideally each dog antler would be the right texture, size, smoothness, thickness and just tough enough so it doesn’t break. In reality, it depends on the manufacturer who has made them, how they are sanded down and their “natural” characteristics.

As with any online product, make sure to check it over first to confirm it is new and unused. Although it is rare, some Amazon users have reported getting products that they believe were exchanged or refunded and just sent on to the next person instead of brand new. Make sure to let Amazon know this ahead of time. The goal is for your dog to get a toxin-free, contaminant-free product.

Some dog owners prefer all-natural products with no additional additives or chemicals. Others may not be so strict about it. Know what your deal-breakers are ahead of time, so you can find the kind of antler you’ll need. Some makers are so adamant about all-natural, organic products that even the plastic wrap is eco-friendly. Others use whatever’s available.

While the plastic usage is a matter of preference, the type of dog antler being used is not. If you’re unsure which brand makes the most sense for your dog (or size or texture), ask your veterinarian ahead of time. Chances are pretty high that your veterinarian has experienced many types of dog antlers and knows which ones are safer than others. It is better to take the opinion of a dog health professional over the dog brand or marketing company. The former should always make your dog the priority.

Antler Storage Tips

Australian shepherd standing on hind legs and trying to reach a bone on the top of a pedestal against white background

Once you have the best antler option down, then decide whether you want a whole or split antler, depending on the dog’s size and behavior. Keep in mind that some dogs in the same household may be gentler chewers than others. If so, keep the two antlers separate.

Try not to keep the dog antlers in a crate where the dog can hide it. It would too easily be forgotten. If your dog ends up in a crate, and unattended, then this gives him too much time to get creative. Keep the antler in plain sight, maybe an open dog bed.

When the antler is not being played with, find a high shelf or counter to keep it until next use. If you have a larger dog who is a counter surfer, counters just won’t do. Try closed cabinets or the tops of refrigerators to make sure this dog doesn’t try to get ahold of anything he’s not supposed to without you being able to see him.

How to Recognize When Antlers Should Be Discarded

boxer puppy eating a bone

The goal of an antler is to chew on it, not bite and digest it like it’s regular food. Once you see your dog chomping on it like it’s food, pay especially close attention. You may have to remove it altogether at that point unless you can figure out a way to distract the dog from more aggressive measures. If you can remove the splintered area and keep the remainder of the antler intact, consider this.

Some dog owners choose to put something on the marrow to slow down the process. For example, peanut butter is usually an easy option for dogs to want to lick around (unless they are allergic). (Try to find a clean spot so you don’t end up with peanut butter all over your carpet or easily-stained tile floors.) Once the peanut butter is off and they go back to gnawing, you’ll probably be OK for a while.

But the marrow should be able to break in half or large parts instead of splintering like a stick. Once it starts to splinter (imagine a breaking toothpick), it’s time to remove those split pieces. If it continues to splinter, discard it altogether and purchase a new one.

Bottom Line

While it is highly recommended to brush your dog’s teeth two to three times a week, antlers are great for tartar control. They’re also a fantastic source of natural calcium, phosphorus, manganese and zinc.

With that said, the American Kennel Club points out that veterinarians commonly complain about antlers as the source of a dog’s broken tooth. If not treated immediately, broken teeth can be painful and lead to abscesses and infections (1).

If the chewing is not watched carefully, splintered pieces can also become lodged into your dog’s mouth, throat and/or intestines. With that said, there are plenty of dogs who never have health issues when it comes to this time-friendly treat.

Finding versions that do not fit completely into their mouths helps some. But more importantly, make sure to supervise your dog while he’s eating this. As enjoyable as it may be for him, treat an antler the same way you would a child with a small toy. Let them “play” with it without things getting out of hand.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here